Your bag is empty,
Let's fix that!

Shop from Bestsellers

Supergreat Logo
eyebrow pencils on orange background


Here Are the 5 Best Eyebrow Pencils, According to Your Reviews

by @abigailrena
Jun 09, 2020


Honest question: Do people still say “eyebrows on fleek” or am I aging myself by bringing up that phrase? Either way, we all strive for perfect brows, whether that’s fluffy or sharp, arched or straight. There are hundreds of brow products on the market to help us achieve our brow goals from brow pomades to brow gels, but perhaps the most popular brow products are eyebrow pencils. These slim sticks of pigment make shaping and filling in your brows easy and ultra-precise. Because eyebrow pencils are the hero product for novice brow fillers and expert brow shapers, the market is flooded with them. Nearly every brand has their own version of this eyebrow product, but they aren’t all the same. Luckily, our Supergreaters are experts in this area. They have reviewed several eyebrow pencils, but these are the five best ones, according to their reviews.

1. Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

Wouldn’t it be nice if we could wave a magic wand and our brows would filled? Anastasia Beverly Hills’ Brow Wiz is probably the closest thing we will get to magic. This $23 product is dual ended with a twistable eyebrow pencil on one side and a spoolie brush on the other. It comes in 10 shades from blonde to granite. The fine tip on this brow pencil helps to mimic hair-like strokes with a high payoff wax formula. ABH makes brow filling as easy as it can be.

Watch more Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz reviews.

2. e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil

When you’re just starting to fill in your brows and you don’t know whether you’re a pencil person or a pomade person, it can be hard to justify spending over $10 on an eyebrow pencil. Luckily e.l.f. always comes to the rescue with affordable, quality products. The Instant Lift Brow Pencil from e.l.f. retails for only $2! That price can’t be beaten. It comes in six shades from blonde to black with a retractable wax formula on one side and a large spoolie brush on the other side. This product is perfect for brow beginners.

Watch more e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil reviews.

3. ColourPop Brow Boss Pencil

Eyebrows can make or break a makeup look. Because of that, eyebrows are kind of like the boss of your other facial features — If they look poorly managed, the rest of your makeup will look messy too. ColourPop has just the eyebrow pencil to give your brows a much-deserved promotion, after all, they do keep dust out of your eyes and that’s hard work! The Brow Boss Pencil retails for $6 and comes in nine shades from cool blonde to soft black. Use the twistable product on one end to add hair-like strokes and the spoolie on the other end to blend out harsh lines and comb your hairs into place.

Watch more ColourPop Brow Boss Pencil reviews.

4. Urban Decay Brow Blade Ink Stain + Waterproof Pencil

On days when you might come into contact with water, whether it’s from the rain or a splash by the pool, make sure your eyebrows don’t slip halfway down your face with Urban Decay’s Brow Blade Ink Stain + Waterproof Pencil. This $26 brow pencil is unique because one is your normal, waterproof brow pencil, but the other is an ink pen. It’s the perfect product if you’re looking for a microbladed look without the commitment. Use the ink pen to draw on fine hairs and the brow pencil to fill in the rest.

Watch more Urban Decay Brow Blade Ink Stain + Waterproof Pencil reviews.

5. Benefit Cosmetics Precisely My Brow Pencil

The key to a good brow pencil is precision. Benefit Cosmetics Precisely My Brow Pencil has an ultra-fine tip, which makes it easier to apply the product only where you want it to go. The top of the pencil twists to reveal the product, while the bottom of the pencil contains a hidden spoolie under a uniquely shaped cap. This $24 brow pencil comes in 12 shades including cool gray for our more mature makeup lovers or those who simply decided to dye their hair a silvery gray with brows to match.

Watch more Benefit Cosmetics Precisely My Brow Pencil reviews.

Which eyebrow pencils do you use for snatched brows? Make a review and add it below!

32 Community responses

Your bag is empty,
Let's fix that!

Shop from Bestsellers